Intermediaries

How London Coffee Houses Gave Rise to the Broker

Exchange Alley, Jonathan's and a printed list of prices: how informal meeting places turned dealers into a profession with rules.

  • By the Cana Tradero editorial team
  • Published
  • 5 min read

In Amsterdam, the first station on our line, shares changed hands on a bridge and then in a purpose-built courtyard. London took a different route. Its market for shares grew up in rooms that served coffee, and the people who ran it were not company officials but a new kind of professional: the broker.

This article follows that journey, from the narrow lanes near the Royal Exchange to the first building that called itself the Stock Exchange, and asks what the coffee houses actually contributed.

Out of the Royal Exchange

By the 1690s London had several large joint-stock companies whose shares could be transferred, including the East India Company, founded in 1600, and the Hudson's Bay Company, chartered in 1670 to trade in the territories that later became part of Canada. The Bank of England, established in 1694, added another widely held stock and a growing market in government debt.

Merchants traditionally met at the Royal Exchange on Cornhill, but share dealers were a noisy, fast-moving group and did not fit easily alongside traders in cloth and spices. Over the 1690s they moved into the coffee houses of Exchange Alley, a tangle of lanes between Cornhill and Lombard Street. Coffee had arrived in London only a few decades earlier, and coffee houses had quickly become places where people read news, met clients and did business for the price of a drink.

A table and a price list

Two coffee houses, Jonathan's and Garraway's, became the centre of the trade. A dealer could be found at a regular table at regular hours, and reputation travelled quickly in a crowded room. That alone reduced the cost of finding a counterparty.

The decisive step was information. From 1698 a broker named John Castaing published from Jonathan's a sheet called The Course of the Exchange, issued twice a week, listing prices for leading stocks, government debt and foreign exchange rates. For the first time, someone outside the room could see what shares had recently sold for. A private bargain had become a public price.

Words from Exchange Alley
Broker
An agent who buys or sells on behalf of a client and earns a commission for doing so.
Jobber
A dealer who buys and sells on their own account, holding shares in between and earning the difference in price.
Price list
A regular published record of recent prices, such as Castaing's sheet, that lets outsiders compare bargains.
Joint-stock company
A company whose capital is divided into transferable shares held by many investors.

Licences and a bubble

An open market also attracted suspicion. Many people believed that dealers manipulated prices, and in 1697 Parliament passed an act to restrain the number and practices of brokers and stockjobbers. It required brokers in the City of London to be licensed and limited their number to one hundred. Enforcement was uneven, but the principle that intermediaries could be regulated had been established.

The great test came in 1720. Shares in the South Sea Company, which had taken over a large part of the government's debt, rose dramatically and then collapsed within months. Dozens of new schemes had appeared in Exchange Alley during the boom, some with little more than a name. Parliament responded with the Bubble Act, which restricted the creation of joint-stock companies without a charter. The act stayed in force until 1825 and shaped British company law for a century.

For the brokers, the lesson was that their trade depended on public trust. A market seen as a gambling den would be legislated against; a market seen as orderly would be tolerated.

From coffee house to exchange

Over the eighteenth century the regulars at Jonathan's gradually turned into an organization. After a fire on Cornhill in 1748, the coffee house was rebuilt and the dealers returned. In 1761 a group of around 150 brokers and jobbers formed a club to use the room on their own terms. In 1773 they moved into a new building nearby, first called New Jonathan's and soon renamed the Stock Exchange.

The change from coffee house to exchange mattered because a coffee house was open to anyone who bought a drink. A club could set conditions: members paid a subscription, followed rules and could be excluded for failing to honour a bargain. In 1801 membership became formal and subscription-based, and in 1802 the Stock Exchange opened a new building in Capel Court.

What the coffee houses left

The coffee houses did not invent shares, which came from the joint-stock companies, nor the idea of a fixed meeting place, which Amsterdam already had. What they produced was the professional intermediary: a broker or jobber whose livelihood depended on reputation, regular presence and published prices. The distinction between those two roles lasted in London until the reforms of 1986.

When we travel to New York in 1792, we will meet a group of brokers solving the same problem in the same way: by agreeing among themselves who could trade, and on what terms.

Educational content, not advice. This article describes historical events for learning purposes. It does not recommend any investment, and past market behaviour is not a reliable indicator of future results.

Next stop: Under the Buttonwood Tree: The 1792 Agreement and Early New York

Change here for

Want to see every station on the network?

Back to Research Explore the learning areas